We've made homemade pizza a few times but we haven't gotten around to doing what we really wanted to do: making grilled pizza. So last night we did just that.
First I started by making the dough. If you haven't discovered this stuff yet:
you need to get some ASAP. Making your own dough is easy (obviously, because I can do it) and it is SO much better than store bought. We started
making our own pizza dough and haven't looked back since. This yeast makes it ten times easier because you don't have to wait to let it rise, you just mix up and bake!
Pizza Dough
2 1/4 cups all-purpose flour
1 envelope pizza dough yeast
1.5 teaspoons sugar
3/4 teaspoon salt
2/3 cup very warm water
3 tablespoons oil (I've found this is optional...really I just forgot it once and the crust was fine)
This dough is a little stickier than bread dough so just keep flour on your hands while you're mixing it!
I have a tendency to read through recipes too fast, missing key steps or ingredients (ahem like the oil in the above recipe). Last night was no different. I started mixing together the pizza dough ingredients and used 1 tablespoon of sugar. As I dumped it in the bowl something in my head yelled: TEASPOOOOOON. But it was too late. Sugar isn't something that can be easily fished out of a bowl full of flour, so I had to just hope it wouldn't make too much of a difference (it didn't). After that I stretched out the dough and got the toppings assembled for our first pizza.
Yes I have tried throwing it up in the air, no it did not work. I almost dropped it on Basher's head because he was sitting at my feet watching and thinking "She's really going to try it, I gotta see this."
I purposely made the dough a little thicker than I would have if we baked it so it would be easier to manage. I also made our own red sauce for this one (mainly because I couldn't find pizza sauce for the life of me in the grocery store...seriously, why is not with the pasta sauce? or the tomato products?).
I mixed together one can of tomato sauce and one can of Basil, Garlic & Oregano tomato paste. I know you usually don't use that amount of tomato paste in this small of a batch of...well anything, but one of the things that annoys me most about my cooking is my sauces never thicken up. We wanted a good thick sauce so I wasn't going to slack off this time. I also sprinkled in some of this:
I really had planned to just sort of wing the whole grilling thing. I was putting this amazing olive oil on the dough:
When another little voice in my head (It's like I had
Ratatouille in there last night...which could be possible, we've discovered we have mice...but that's a story for another day) said: "Hey maybe you should look at a recipe, you know so you don't ruin this." Ah, the voice of reason. I don't know whose voice it is but it saved our dinner last night.
Jess' plan: to put the toppings on the dough and throw it on the grill like you would put it in the oven.
How you actually do it: you have to let the dough cook for 2-3 minutes BEFORE putting the toppings on.
Doughy, uncooked crisis narrowly averted.
This
How to Grill Pizza article came in handy, and the fact that I'd already spread the olive oil all over the dough actually worked to my advantage because it helped the dough not stick to the grill.
I wish we'd video taped Ty and I trying to getting the dough onto and off of the grill. It was the opposite of everything you've ever seen Bobby Flay do. I took the first shot and tried to flip the dough from the pan onto the grill with the oiled side down.
Note to self: grills are hot. When you drop pizza dough on one, don't try to pick it up and rearrange it. Second go round I let Ty make the dough drop, he did a much better job. Once you have the dough properly on the grill, you close the lid and let it cook about 2 minutes if your grill is pretty hot, maybe 3 if not, and you get this:
Yeah, YUM. So now one side of the dough is cooked and your ready to add the toppings to that side. We made two pizzas last night: pepperoni with my super thick and delicious red sauce and a Hawaiian with ham, pineapple, and no sauce just a layer of ricotta cheese spread on it first (oh and a little more of that Italian herb Garlic Gold).
Once the toppings are on, it's back to the grill for another 2-3 minutes. It is much easier to put it on the grill the second time since it's now holding it's shape!
The Verdict:
Grilling the dough makes this amazing thick crunchy/chewy crust, we could not believe how awesome this pizza was!
Of course Ty had to break out the
party cut.
And I had to break out the wine :)
This wine is Apple-Strawberry Shortcake, it is really sweet but great for a summer afternoon, which is what it sort of felt like in Virginia yesterday! This bottle was brought to us straight from Bedford where the winery is by my bridesmaid Bekah :)
Tips for next time:
Pre-cook some toppings: The first thing I noticed making this grilled pizza is that it cooks really, really quickly. So next time we're going to pre-cook some of our toppings because they really don't have time to cook while they're on the pizza. Our pepperonis were fine but really they were just warmed up, not crispy like usual. If you were going to use veggies I would definitely saute them first!
Pre-assemble everything: This is a chronic issue for me. I really should have prepared both doughs and set out all the toppings instead of trying to make the second dough while the first was cooking. It made for a lot of scrambling around, which I know amuses our cats but that's also how I forget ingredients or important steps.
What are your favorite pizza toppings when you make pizza at home?